Whatnot Organic Growth Opportunities

Readiness Assessment

Domain Authority
53
Organic Search Traffic
474.99K
Organic Keywords
181.63K
Current Performance
  • Driving 475k monthly organic visits from over 182k keywords, with an equivalent ad spend value of $113k.
  • Your organic performance is heavily reliant on brand recognition, with the keywords "whatnot" and "what not" alone accounting for over 80% of all search traffic.
  • The domain has a solid Authority Score of 53, built upon a foundation of 2.2m backlinks from 16k referring domains, indicating a trustworthy and established online presence.
Growth Opportunity
  • The vast majority of your 182k ranking keywords are long-tail or misspellings of your brand, highlighting a significant opportunity to target high-volume, non-branded keywords related to your core categories (e.g., collectibles, sneakers, fashion).
  • Your homepage currently captures nearly 90% of all organic traffic, signaling a major opportunity to build out and optimize category, product, and seller pages to attract users with specific purchase intent.
  • Informational content on your help subdomain (e.g., "flat rate shipping") already ranks for non-branded terms, providing a proven template to expand your content strategy and capture users earlier in the buying journey.
Assessment

You have a powerful organic presence built on exceptional brand strength, but this currently limits your reach to users already familiar with your platform. There is a substantial, untapped opportunity to capture high-intent traffic by systematically creating and optimizing pages for non-branded search terms. AirOps can help you scale this content strategy across your thousands of categories and listings to unlock significant new growth.

Your domain is ready for AI powered growth

Competition at a Glance

An analysis of 2 direct competitors confirms whatnot.com's dominant market leadership, generating 474,994 monthly organic visits from 181,629 ranking keywords. This performance firmly establishes your brand as the top destination for organic search traffic within this competitive set.

The nearest competitor, TikTok Shop, attracts 69,351 monthly organic visits and ranks for 11,886 keywords. This highlights a significant performance gap, with whatnot.com's keyword footprint being over 15 times larger and driving nearly 7 times more organic traffic.

This substantial lead demonstrates a clear opportunity to further extend your market leadership. The current competitive moat is significant, providing a strong position to capture even more share of voice before competitors can invest in closing the gap.

Opportunity Kickstarters

Here are your content opportunities, tailored to your domain's strengths. These are starting points for strategic plays that can grow into major traffic drivers in your market. Connect with our team to see the full traffic potential and activate these plays.

1. Condition-Grade Price Matrix Pages

Content Creation
Programmatic SEO
Content Refresh

Create a massive library of pages detailing the market price for every collectible item at each specific condition grade (e.g., PSA 8, CGC 9.6). This play captures extremely high-intent searchers looking for precise valuation data before buying or selling.

Example Keywords
  • “psa 8 umbreon gold star value”
  • “cgc 9.6 uncanny x-men 266 price”
  • “beckett 9 michael jordan fleer 1986 worth”
  • “sneaker condition rating 7 vs 9 price difference”
Rationale

Collectors and investors search for precise, grade-specific pricing information. By providing a comprehensive price matrix using its own transaction data, Whatnot can become the definitive source for valuation, intercepting users at the final stage of their research before a purchase.

Topical Authority

Whatnot possesses millions of data points on graded collectible sales, a proprietary asset that competitors like eBay or grading companies themselves do not publish in an aggregated, user-friendly format. Publishing this data establishes Whatnot as the market's most transparent and authoritative pricing resource.

Internal Data Sources

This play leverages the transaction ledger segmented by item and grade, population counts from grading company APIs, and hosted images of the actual graded items (slabs) from past listings.

Estimated Number of Pages

1,600,000+

2. Collectible Price-Guide & Recent-Sales Pages

Content Creation
Programmatic SEO
Content Refresh

Generate an item-level price guide page for every unique collectible SKU that has a significant transaction history on the platform. These pages serve as a central hub for an item's market value, recent sales trends, and upcoming auctions.

Example Keywords
  • “charizard vstar 2022 price”
  • “air jordan 1 chicago resale value”
  • “funko pop #01 price guide”
  • “amazing fantasy 15 graded 3.0 price”
Rationale

Price discovery is a primary activity for all collectors. By creating dedicated price guide pages, Whatnot captures high-funnel research traffic and can immediately convert that interest by showing live and upcoming auctions for that specific item.

Topical Authority

As a major marketplace, Whatnot has first-party, real-time sales data that is more current and reliable than competitor data, which often relies on scraping or manual entry. This gives Whatnot a significant advantage in building topical authority around market pricing and trends.

Internal Data Sources

The core data includes the transaction ledger (final hammer prices, condition, date), auto-generated charts showing 30/90/365-day price trends, and photos from actual sold listings.

Estimated Number of Pages

200,000+

3. Localized 'Buy & Sell Near Me' Pages

Content Creation
Programmatic SEO
Content Refresh

Create geo-targeted landing pages that combine a product category with a specific city or metro area. These pages surface local sellers, highlight faster shipping times, and cater to users searching with local intent.

Example Keywords
  • “sneaker auctions in Atlanta”
  • “pokemon card breaks Los Angeles time zone”
  • “live coin auctions UK”
  • “funko pop auction Toronto”
Rationale

Searches including 'near me' or specific locations signal a high degree of trust-seeking and logistical concern (e.g., shipping speed). By creating pages that address these needs directly, Whatnot can capture valuable local search traffic that competitors ignore.

Topical Authority

While topical authority for local terms may need to be built, Whatnot has a unique advantage by knowing the physical location of its thousands of sellers. It can use this data to create genuinely useful local pages that surface sellers from a user's region, something a generic e-commerce site cannot do.

Internal Data Sources

This play utilizes seller origin ZIP codes to filter live shows, historical shipping time averages for origin-destination pairs, and flags for local pickup eligibility to provide unique, localized value.

Estimated Number of Pages

100,000+

4. Variant & Exclusive Edition Explainer Pages

Content Creation
Programmatic SEO
Content Refresh

Develop detailed guide pages for every minor variant, special edition, or convention-exclusive version of popular collectibles. These pages explain the rarity and origin of each variant, targeting hyper-specific, long-tail search queries from serious collectors.

Example Keywords
  • “funko pop voltaic purple meaning”
  • “jordan 1 low atmosphere grey release details”
  • “batman #50 j scott campbell variant value”
  • “labubu sweet dream chase ratio”
Rationale

The most dedicated collectors hunt for obscure variants, and their searches are often answered by low-authority forums or Reddit threads. Whatnot can win this high-intent traffic by creating authoritative, well-structured pages that also link directly to live listings for those items.

Topical Authority

By cataloging and explaining the universe of collectible variants, Whatnot demonstrates a level of expertise that builds immense trust and authority. This positions the brand as a resource for both novice and expert collectors.

Internal Data Sources

Leverage the internal product database which contains flags for variant names, the sold-price distribution for each variant to create value charts, and Getty Images for clean hero photos.

Estimated Number of Pages

60,000+

5. Brand-Category Live-Auction Landing Pages

Content Creation
Programmatic SEO
Content Refresh

Build static landing pages for every popular Brand and Category combination available on Whatnot (e.g., 'Nike Sneakers,' 'Funko Pop Toys'). These pages act as evergreen hubs that introduce the topic and funnel users directly into relevant live auctions.

Example Keywords
  • “nike sneaker live auction”
  • “pokemon cards live break”
  • “funko pop live sale”
  • “lego minifigure live auction”
Rationale

Users often search by brand and category before they are aware of specific products or sellers. These pages capture that mid-funnel intent and serve as the perfect bridge, educating the user while simultaneously showcasing Whatnot's core value proposition: live shopping.

Topical Authority

Whatnot already has immense authority for branded search terms like 'whatnot' and its core feature, 'live auctions.' Combining these two areas of strength by creating dedicated Brand + Auction pages is a natural extension that leverages existing authority to rank for new, high-value commercial keywords.

Internal Data Sources

Utilize the internal brand and category taxonomy to generate the pages, historical sales data (GMV) for social proof, and seller rating data to highlight top-rated sellers for that category.

Estimated Number of Pages

62,500+

6. Striking Distance Audit: Seller Help & Onboarding SEO

Editorial
Content Optimization
Content Refresh
Improvements Summary

Consolidate fragmented seller help content into authoritative pillar pages, optimize for high-volume keywords, and strengthen internal linking to improve rankings for seller onboarding queries. Add schema markup, interactive tools, and new content formats to capture rich snippets and drive organic traffic.

Improvements Details

Key tasks include merging and expanding articles on topics like 'how to sell on whatnot', 'seller fees', and 'shipping', retitling and restructuring pages with clear H2s and embedded videos, and implementing FAQ/HowTo schema. The /seller page will become a hub linking to deep-dive resources, while new content such as comparison blog posts, case studies, and an interactive fee calculator will target additional search intent. Internal links from all seller articles will point to the hub, and a 'Seller Resources' footer will surface the cluster sitewide.

Improvements Rationale

Current content is thin and scattered, causing poor rankings despite high search demand and low competition. Consolidating and optimizing pages will signal authority to search engines, while schema and internal links will improve visibility and user navigation. These changes are expected to drive significant organic traffic and increase seller sign-ups by capturing more relevant queries and improving user experience.

Appendix

Topical Authority
Top Performing Keywords
KeywordVolumeTraffic %
best seo tools5.0k3
seo strategy4.0k5
keyword research3.5k2
backlink analysis3.0k4
on-page optimization2.5k1
local seo2.0k6
Top Performing Pages
PageTrafficTraffic %
/seo-tools5.0k100
/keyword-research4.0k100
/backlink-checker3.5k80
/site-audit3.0k60
/rank-tracker2.5k50
/content-optimization2.0k40

Ready to Get Growing?

Request access to the best–in–class growth strategies and workflows with AirOps

Book a Demo